Saltwater Fish Species Guide
   
 
George Hickox

Electronic Collar Training

by George Hickox

A few years ago I attended the Outdoor Writers Association of America’s annual conference on behalf of Nova Scotia Tourism. I had flown two of my dogs to the gathering, as I was scheduled to do some training exhibitions. The dogs performed admirably with tail wagging style, and after the event two members of the audience approached me. They complimented me on the dogs, then commented on how nice it was to see dogs trained without an electronic collar.

Well, guess what? I do use an electronic collar. In fact when used correctly, the collar can be a marvelous tool for any dog trainer. "Correctly" is the key word here, as a collar used incorrectly can produce disastrous results as can any training method not properly employed.

There was a time when I opposed the use of electronics in training. I had the same misconceptions that some other trainers have that the collar was cruel and that I’d be ruining dogs or creating robots that simply reacted to the touch of a button But I’ve acquired much knowledge through working with many dogs over many years and sharing information with other trainers. Over time I’ve learned about the proper use of electronics and about the benefits to be gained from them. In this column I will attempt to pass on some of this knowledge and eliminate the perceived voodoo surrounding this effective training tool.

If you are to use the collar, it is paramount that you understand that punishment training giving a command and punishing for noncompliance without offering the dog incentives to perform before being punished as the sole approach will result in a dog that responds only when it’s afraid of being punished. As soon as the dog is off the check cord and not wearing the collar it will say, To hell with you! At best you will have a dog that performs inconsistently.

This is why many trainers go wrong from the start. "My dog is running too big and won’t come. I’m going to get one of those collars and give him an education." So the frustrated owner buys a collar, puts it on the dog, casts the dog out and then commands it to come. Fido is enjoying himself and would rather run. So the owner shocks the dog or, as we now say, stimulates it. The dog usually does one of three things: It runs as far as it can as quickly as it can, and after 10 seconds the collar automatically shuts off (a built in safety feature). Thus the dog learns that if it bolts like a runaway train, the stimulation will eventually shut off. A second option is that the dog freezes on the spot, and after 10 seconds the stimulation goes away. Thus the dog learns to grit its teeth until the stimulation disappears. In both cases the dog is starting to become case hardened and the owner will have to use increasing amounts of punishment down the road.

The third likely response is that the dog runs back to its owner. Great, huh? No, not great. When the dog runs back the stimulation turns off. Dogs are extremely place oriented, and the dog may have just learned that being away from its owner is dangerous and that the area near its owner’s boots is a sanctuary. Getting the dog to cast out to hunt from now on could be difficult.

Obviously, this is the wrong way to introduce a dog to the collar. To maximize the benefits of this device, you must teach electronic training to the dog. You want the collar to produce a bold and confident dog one that is happy and performs with enthusiasm.

For about two months before they are introduced to stimulation, my pups wear a dummy collar every time they go out. As you can imagine, at the end of the two months the youngsters start jumping up and down with excitement whenever they spot the collar in my hand. The collar is now associated with running, having fun and finding birds. It is a bad idea to stimulate a dog the first time it wears a collar, as you risk making the dog collar wise and responsive only when it’s wearing the device.

When I am ready to move on to formal training or training that involves correctionI want a collar that has variable intensity levels and continuous stimulation. At this stage I want the stimulation to stay on for as long as I depress the button (up to 10 seconds), providing continuous pressure as opposed to a momentary reminder.


Before I actually use the collar in training, I must first find the level of stimulation to which the do responds. I cannot assume that because Buster is a hard headed son of a gun that he will be a level seven, whereas Suzie, a more sensitive dog, will be a level one. To find the proper level, I begin with the lowest and keep the stimulation on. I look for some sign of acknowledgment perhaps the dog stops panting for a moment or perks up a quizzical ear. I place my finger on the dog’s neck and feel for an involuntary muscle twitch when stimulation is applied. If I see or feel no response, I move up successive levels until the dog shows some response without yelping or panicking. This will be the level at which to start.

The beauty of this is that the dog tells me how much discipline is needed. Some training manuals call for using "the proper amount" of correction. How do you know what the proper amount is? With the electronic collar, you know. The collar makes prior experience in reading a dog less important.

Once I have found the proper level of stimulation, I am ready to teach the dog how to turn the stimulation off. But before I actually apply stimulation, I must first show the dog what I want. I put a check cord on the dog and stand within a couple of feet of a portable kennel. I give the command "Kennel" over and over as I lead the dog into the box. Once I’ve done this enough times that I am confident the dog knows the meaning of the command, I am ready to apply some pressure.

I turn on the stimulation first, then immediately follow with the command "Kennel" given once. The stimulation remains on until the dog is in the kennel, whereupon it goes off. I am teaching the dog that the kennel is a sanctuary a place where there is never stimulation. This is an important concept for the dog to learn, as I will employ the sanctuary concept in other aspects of the dog’s training.

Once the dog knows how to turn the stimulation off by going into the kennel, I start with the command "Kennel," then follow with stimulation only if the dog does not perform and I keep the stimulation on until the dog is within six feet of the kennel and heading toward it. If the dog is heading for the kennel and then turns away at the last minute, stimulation is again applied until the dog obeys. Remember, at this stage I am only giving the command one time. The dog will gain confidence and style once he discovers that he can beat the stimulation by responding quickly.

Once I can send the pup into the kennel from 20 yards or so, I am ready to teach "Sit," or "Hup," to the flushing breeds and "Whoa!’ to the pointing breeds. The method is the same as with teaching "Kennel." I show the dog what the command means, repeating it all the while. Then I apply stimulation, give the command once and stop the stimulation upon performance.

I teach "Here" the same way. I show the dog "Here" by pulling it to me with a check cord while repeating the command. After the "show me" phase, I apply stimulation first, give the command and stop the stimulation as soon as the dog complies. Once the dog knows how to turn the stimulation off, I give the command first and apply stimulation only if the dog does not obey. Ultimately, the command is given and the dog performs with no stimulation.

Once I have conditioned the dog to the collar, I am able to use this tool in all aspects of my training, including bird work. Mother Nature gave the pup three methods for solving problems: running away, biting and sulking. I gave the dog a problem by turning the stimulation on. It could either run, bite or sulk, but none of these things solved its problem the stimulation stayed on. Complying with the command did. I then taught the pup that if it responded quickly, it avoided the problem altogether. This made the dog happy and confident because it had found the solution.

Which reminds me of the story about the guy who was always snapping his fingers, which drove his wife crazy. Finally the wife insisted that her husband seek professional help. The doctor asked why the husband was always snapping his fingers, to which the husband replied that he was afraid of lions and that the snapping was what kept the lions away.

"Why, there isn’t a lion within 5,000 miles of here!" the doctor exclaimed.

"See?" the husband replied. "It works."

The electronic collar should not be thought of as a training shortcut. You still need to develop habit through repetition. Think of keeping the lions away and establishing sanctuaries. If the collar is not used only as a punishment device, it will help develop a well trained dog that hunts in control and with style.

Editor’s Note: This article first appeared in the September/October 1997 issue of Shooting Sportsman, "The Magazine of Wingshooting and Fine Guns." Be sure to visit www.shootingsportsman.com.

About the Author: Following a successful field trial career, George has focused his energies on the George Hickox School of Dog Training. This widely acclaimed, five-day program is limited to 12 students and their dogs per session at host facilities across the U.S. This program has developed a world-class reputation for bringing out the best in young dogs while providing a wealth of dog training knowledge to novice and seasoned handlers alike. George is also the Hunting Dogs Editor for Shooting Sportsman magazine and the host/producer of several award-winning videos. He recently co-authored a book for training flushing dogs: Hunt’em Up! For more information on training products, books, videos or Grouse Wing services, visit www.georgehickox.com.